Tomorrow will mark the end of what I can only describe as an excruciating period as a member of this OUSD community. Read on for details, but here's what has happened in just the last couple of weeks:
- An independent review for Alameda County found no signs of fraud in how OUSD used parcel tax funds to help with its decades-long fiscal woes, even though the measures' own oversight commission says it's not what voters intended.
- ACOE Superintendent Alysse Castro published two parts of a six-part series about OUSD, with fairly strong signals to the voting public, right as people are going to vote.
- District 4 School Board Director Mike Hutchinson, for reasons known only to him, chose his perch on the school board to dismiss and de-legitimize the community engagement efforts of a non-political, self-funded volunteer organization I helped create. The community and I responded to his face last Wednesday.
- Jill Tucker of the SF Chronicle published a woefully biased and misleading article about OUSD just days before our board election. Her story left out (ignored?) a couple of details that pretty much destroy its entire framing. Yeesh.
I'll cover these in order, from the things that make me feel the most sick to the least-most sick.
Jill Tucker vs. Journalistic Integrity
For the year or so that I've been volunteering and seeing actual fiscal progress at OUSD, I can tell you there's always a collective shudder that goes through many of us when the San Francisco Chronicle's education reporter decides to publish a story about our district.
If you choose to read Jill Tucker's reporting, I would like you to make a very real assessment about whether or not you believe she's a truly independent reporter on this beat. I'm not going to dedicate an entire blog post to it (yet), but I've included some examples for you in the footnotes.1 At any rate, she clearly couldn't wait to publish this article, because she brushed right past the most important fact in the report she covers.
Since the details here are a bit arcane, I'll hit you with a bulleted list:
- FCMAT (the Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team) is a state-supported organization that gets called in to help districts in financial trouble.
- One form that help takes is a written assessment of risks and challenges called the FHRA.
- OUSD is one of a dozen districts FCMAT has published an FHRA for this year, and the reports are all public.
- The last 40 reports FCMAT published since 2024 all put the district they're assessing at a "high risk" of insolvency. Yep, all of them.2
- On Friday, Jill Tucker reported that OUSD is saying its finances are "fine," but that FCMAT's report shows otherwise.3
- When the board's leaders pointed out that the analysis was based on an earlier budget update, she waved it off, noting FCMAT "used the spring budget update as well as actual budget passed in June." FCMAT did look at those, but only in notes: the score, and every answer behind it, is based on OUSD's finances up to January 31, 2026. After 30 years on the beat, you'd think she'd know the difference.
If you'd like to know the gist of what she wrote, here's a key quote from her:
"The conclusion reached by the Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team, or FCMAT, contradicts months of upbeat messaging by Oakland school officials who have insisted the district's finances are not only fine, but in fact something 'worth celebrating.'"
The entire premise of this run-on sentence is provably false, and so much of it makes me ill to even have to address. Considering Jill Tucker's troubling history of politically biased and misleading reporting, I feel compelled to break down the two things that are most important:
- Yes, district leaders were upbeat in May, when the Third Interim showed the district could meet its obligations. But had Jill Tucker attended (or even actually watched) any recent OUSD school board meetings, she'd know that "Oakland school officials" are definitely not saying the district's finances are "fine." There are so many examples of district staff telling everyone, consistently, that we're still in a deep financial hole that I don't even know where to start.4
- The FCMAT report doesn't contradict months of any messaging, "upbeat" or otherwise. This is because (and it's plain to read) the risk score is based on Second Interim numbers as of January 31, 2026. FCMAT annotated a few later filings, but those notes didn't change a single answer. By FCMAT's own description, the report focuses on systems and processes and measures risk at the time of evaluation; it doesn't score the 2026-27 budget or the trajectory it sets.5
This kind of lazy reporting is truly exhausting, and irresponsible, when said reporting shapes discussions affecting the outcomes of public school students. It's also pretty exhausting that I spent a good part of my weekend reading and assessing what the report actually says, just so I could publish a companion post about it. But that's probably my own fault.
Spoiler alert: The risk score would likely be lower if they actually used numbers and reports from after January 31, and nothing in the report is new information, at all. Please read about it!
Mike Hutchinson vs. Community Engagement
It's no secret that I don't like the way District 4 Board Director Mike Hutchinson represents his constituency in public. I have a lot of respect for his legacy as a fighter for his community, and I quite honestly agree with him about a lot of stuff. On the other hand, I've now spent over a year attending most board meetings, and I can say unequivocally that his penchant for personal attacks, baseless accusations, and relentless bullying of pretty much everyone else in the room makes it all a pretty awful experience for anyone who has to be there.6
But hey, this is a democracy: if the folks in D4 believe he is representing them properly, he gets to keep doing what he's doing. The thing is, Director Hutchinson now seems to believe he was elected to battle the dreaded scourge of volunteerism, as he said the following publicly about the Multi-Stakeholder Engagement Group (MSEG), right after two other board members praised what we're doing:
"I just want to remind everyone that the MSEG is not a sanctioned group. There's never been a school board vote on it. They were never appointed by the superintendent. They are self-appointed people. And I don't understand why that's being lifted up as some place for work to be done, other than it's a way to not actually engage in the work…"
District 4 Board Director Mike Hutchinson, during his Board Member Report on October 14, 20267
I'm not surprised Director Hutchinson doesn't understand why our work in MSEG is being lifted up; he's never participated with us in any meaningful way, and probably doesn't have any idea what we're doing. I am very surprised he took the opportunity to say that what we're doing is "a way to not actually engage in the work," because, like I said, he's never participated with us in any meaningful way, so how on earth is he qualified to make that statement?
If you are a past participant or supporter of MSEG, thanks! If you're not sure what we do: in general, we're an OUSD community-based group of volunteers from many different groups and perspectives, setting up spaces for public engagement about the many issues our district is facing. It's important (and incredibly difficult) work that has surfaced many discussions the board and district haven't had with the community in any effective format, and it is quite frankly bizarre and infuriating that an active member of the board would attack what we're doing.
So yeah, it made me sick and pissed me (and many others) right off. I felt the need to respond publicly, and I did so backed by a number of people who shared my frustrations.
If this also infuriates you (or if you just like what MSEG does), I strongly encourage you to sign our public statement of support with your email as soon as possible.8 We'd love to show a strong level of support from the community to try to keep our efforts alive in the face of this kind of nonsense.
Superintendent Castro's Ever-Changing Moods
There's no other way to put it: Alameda County Superintendent of Schools Alysse Castro is a tough one to pin down. When I saw that she decided to publish parts I and II of a six-part series about OUSD in the two weeks before a school board election, it made me… queasy.
Then I read this, from Part I:
"The future of OUSD is on the ballot. Three incumbent board members seeking reelection have sharply different visions, with voting records to match, while four challengers offer different—and untested—visions for change."
Am I the only one who sees this as a bit sketchy? Superintendent Castro oversees the fiscal management of OUSD by its board members, and that role is supposed to be apolitical. I'm not saying her insight isn't valuable to the community, but she has been pretty adamant about her distaste for the current board majority not committing to closing schools.9 Publishing this right before the vote feels like she's trying to put her finger on the scale somehow.10
Then Part II came out a week later, and while it didn't land as an op-ed in the Mercury News like the first part did (I gotta ask why it didn't?), it is brimming with praise for the current Superintendent of OUSD, Denise Saddler. In fact, a lot of it sounds like stuff I've been writing for a while in this space:
"One of the changes I respect most in OUSD Superintendent Denise Saddler's tenure is her decision to reconsider something long treated as untouchable: how the district allocates restricted funds."
"Dr. Saddler's team put those assumptions to the test. They froze site-based budgets, identified current and past expenses that could appropriately be paid with restricted dollars, and began using money that had accumulated. They also reviewed longstanding expenses and practices, some of which didn't survive the overhaul.
I applaud that work. Changing what you're willing to put on the table can change what's possible."
How kind! But then, back to the board:
"Dr. Saddler's work has bought time for those decisions. But it cannot substitute for them. And this year, the OUSD School Board's silence on those larger choices has been deafening."
Let's not be coy… "those larger choices" are spelled out a paragraph earlier, and "how many schools to operate" is first on the list. I don't think I'm just imagining that there's some exasperation in her tone here.
As I've written before, I respect Superintendent Castro and think she is very good at her job. Still, to see something with such political flavor released on an ACOE-branded (and taxpayer-funded) newsletter platform, a couple of weeks before a school board election? That distresses me.
The Parcel Tax Thing
This post is already way too long, but I wanted to briefly touch on the ongoing discord around Measure N and Measure H funds, which are an example of a "parcel tax." These taxes were approved by voters, increasing property taxes in Oakland to support some specific public school programs. One of those programs is widely considered a success story at OUSD: the college and career pathways program. Since Measure N started, OUSD's graduation rate has climbed from about 61% to the mid-70s, and the dropout rate has fallen from about 24% to the mid-teens, so it's one of the easier things to support with money here.11
In short, there was a reserve in these funds of about $10 million, much of it unspent during the "planning year" of the program. You may have heard that the district is a bit short on cash these days, so they took about $3.5 million of that reserve and put it toward staffing costs. Those providing oversight of the funds are angry about this and claim the funds are not being used as voters intended. OUSD says it used the funds properly, by paying for staff who serve the programs the measures support.12
I'm only going into this because it is a perfect microcosm of what's been going on at OUSD financially since our last CBO departed. It goes a bit like this:
- The district is running a deficit of some tens of millions of dollars.
- The board and staff don't want to take a loan to cover it; we just got out of receivership.
- OUSD looks in every possible funding source, reserve, and couch cushion to stay solvent. A lot of the money they find has rules attached to it.
- Staff is directed to interpret those rules as widely as possible to close the gap, and they do that.
- They get accused of incompetence, fraud, malfeasance, murder… well, not murder yet.
- Independent auditors look at what OUSD is claiming and find no fraud (or murder). Then the county superintendent shrugs and says, "It looks legal, we sure hope you know what you're doing."13
- Everyone on all sides agrees this isn't sustainable.
Pay close attention to that last point: everyone agrees this isn't sustainable. I've never heard anyone say, "We just fixed everything, what's left over to spend on the party?"
We've got a lot to figure out moving forward, but if we're going to do this in good faith, I'd appreciate some reduction in noise: pointing out that we've made even a little bit of hard-fought progress is not even close to the same as saying the district's finances are "fine." If you equate the two, you're missing the entire point, or maybe you're just Jill Tucker.
Have a great week, and go vote!
Footnotes
-
A few examples, all by Jill Tucker in the Chronicle:
- In September 2025, a headline said OUSD was "on the brink of bankruptcy" (September 12, 2025). California school districts don't go bankrupt; when they run out of cash they take an emergency state loan, which OUSD did in 2003 and finished repaying in 2025. It ended 2025-26 solvent, with no new loan.
- In December 2025, she quoted the departing CBO calling the shift of costs to restricted funds "a precursor to malfeasance and noncompliance" (December 15, 2025). Nine months later, the county superintendent called the same shift "a material change in budgeting methodology," not misconduct; I wrote about that in Alameda County Says OUSD's Progress Is Real.
- In May 2026, when the district's Third Interim showed it could meet its obligations, she wrote that "it would be a miraculous turnaround if true" (May 28, 2026). A papal decree affirming the miracle was provided by Alameda county, which reviewed the same changes line by line and found "a material change in budgeting methodology—not the creation or disappearance of resources."
- The same story as above quotes "parent Arielle Fleisher" as a skeptic. She was Empower Oakland's Policy Lead, drafting its policy positions and sitting on its endorsement committee (LinkedIn), until she stepped back to run. She's now challenging the board president with Empower's endorsement and more than $56,000 of its independent spending (Open Disclosure). The board member the story quotes as a skeptic, Mike Hutchinson, is Empower's #1 pick in District 4.
-
FCMAT published 12 K-12 FHRAs in 2026 and 40 since the start of 2024, and every one rated the district High overall, including districts whose scores fall in the Low and Moderate bands. The chart in my companion post links to each report. ↩
-
Jill Tucker, "Oakland schools touted financial progress. An analysis paints a darker picture", San Francisco Chronicle, October 30, 2026. The story reports the board leaders' objection that the analysis "focuses on an earlier budget update," then counters that FCMAT "used the spring budget update as well as actual budget passed in June." FCMAT did annotate those later filings, but it used the Second Interim "as the basis for the analysis" (report, p. 6), and none of those notes changed an answer, as I walk through in the companion post. ↩
-
In May, Board President Jennifer Brouhard did call the Third Interim "historic" and said the district was "on solid financial footing," and Tucker quotes both. Since then, here's staff's October 28 update to the board on the stabilization plan: "The deficit is ongoing. It is not a one-year problem, and it will not correct itself" (Legistar). The September 23 progress report says the same thing at much greater length. ↩
-
FCMAT used the 2025-26 Second Interim report "because it was the most current financial report at the time the going concern notice was issued" (report, p. 6), and says the analysis "aims to determine the district's level of risk at the time of evaluation" (p. 10). I walk through what that means, with a re-score you can play with, in What the 2026 FCMAT FHRA Says About OUSD IRL. ↩
-
For one documented example, see Director Hutchinson's "missing funds" claims at the June 24 board meeting, which the county's September letter, to my reading, answered directly; it's in note 11 of Alameda County Says OUSD's Progress Is Real. ↩
-
The October 14, 2026 regular meeting of the Board of Education. You can watch the clip here. ↩
-
The statement is at sign.ousd-mseg.org. You can learn more about MSEG and sign up for our engagement platform at ousd-mseg.org. ↩
-
She's blunter in person. At a parent-led community forum on March 16, after describing the schools she's moved and closed, she said, "people don't actually care what building they're located in" (video, 38:50). Later she called families' attachment to their particular school "adult drama that we inflict on kids" (1:05:48). The Oaklandside covered the forum. In print she's more measured: Part I calls the board leadership's choice to "maintain the current number of schools" a "legitimate governing strategy," then argues that "equity can't be measured only by which schools remain open." ↩
-
Part I does say: "I won't endorse candidates or prescribe an educational vision. That's not my role." But it also ran as an op-ed in the Mercury News on October 20, and Empower Oakland quoted it in its October 24 endorsement roundup. That's how it lands, whatever the intent. ↩
-
The Oaklandside puts this year's graduation rate at 76% and the dropout rate at about 14% (October 9, 2026). The district's own Measure N reports show the peak was the class of 2024, at 79.5% with a 10% dropout rate (2023-24 report), before the class of 2025 slipped to 74.0% and 16.9% (2024-25 report). The district credits the pathways; nobody has isolated how much of the gain is theirs. ↩
-
The Oaklandside has good coverage of the whole dispute (October 9, 2026). The Measures N and H Commission's October 6 letter demands the district restore "~$3.5 million" and calls the transfer "unlawful." The county's review, done by the accounting firm Eide Bailly, found the district moved $3.55 million in staff pay and benefits into the measures' accounts in June (report, October 1, 2026). ↩
-
Okay, I'm paraphrasing. The Eide Bailly review found every transferred position is "a kind the Measures permit" and none of the warning signs of fraud or misuse it tested for. It also found $190,853 in overcharges, most of which the district has since reversed, and it explicitly declines to say whether the transfers were proper. The "legal" part is Castro's, from Part II: the transfers were "permissible because the parcel-tax language didn't specify what must happen to unspent funds, leaving the decision to the Board. But legality doesn't settle whether it was what voters thought would be on the table." ↩