On October 29, a state agency called FCMAT published a 55-page report on Oakland Unified's finances.1 It gave the district a risk score of 47.7% and rated OUSD at "High" risk of insolvency. Within a day, the report was being used by political campaigns as proof that nothing has changed at OUSD, that the budget work of the past year was theater, and that the district is headed back toward a state takeover.2
My problem with that: the score is based on a cutoff at Second Interim, which only includes financial records up to January 31, 2026.3 The score mostly measures paperwork and process rather than dollars, and re-scoring it based on all the changes to paperwork and process (and dollars) since then probably lowers it by at least a few points.
So none of what is in the report is news, though it's being reported as if it is. If you want to know whether OUSD is actually on the right track financially, this report is the wrong instrument. The right ones will come in December and January,4 but let's dig in on this report now.
What FCMAT is
FCMAT is the Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team, and it is funded by the state. Its job is to keep districts from becoming insolvent.5 Keep these two things in mind:
- By its own description, FCMAT writes about what needs fixing and generally doesn't comment on what's working, so their reports are always gonna be pretty grim.6
- Under the state budget act, a county superintendent's "going concern" notice (or one of a few similar alarms) puts a district in line for FCMAT review, and that's what Alameda County's notice did for OUSD this year.7
What the FHRA is
FHRA stands for Fiscal Health Risk Analysis. Think of it as a personality test for the school district, with around 130 questions organized into 20 sections.8 Every question is yes or no, such as "Does the district reconcile its bank accounts on time?" or "Has the superintendent been in the job more than two years?"
The questions are weighted, so a "no" on something like reserves counts more than a "no" on facilities utilization, and the score is the weighted share of "no" answers. FCMAT sorts scores into three bands: 24.9% and below is Low, 25% to 39.9% is Moderate, and 40% and up is High. OUSD's 47.7% is well into the High band.9
Note that regardless of the score, many districts end up rated as "High" risk even when they score in the Low or Moderate bands. Check page 38, where you'll see that pretty much any district that has been flagged for review is also going to qualify automatically as high risk.10 Indeed, all 40 FHRAs published since 2024 gave a High rating. I have a chart later!
My point here isn't that we should ignore the High rating, it's that in this report nothing new is contributing to it.
What the 2026 FHRA says about Oakland
The report scored OUSD on its Second Interim budget report, a snapshot of the district's finances as of January 31, 2026. FCMAT says it chose that report because it was the most recent one available when the county issued the going-concern notice in April. FCMAT's actual fieldwork happened in August and in a handful of places the team added notes about things that happened after January.11 Those annotations didn't change any answers or scores. The score is a score from January.
The findings themselves are decidedly not awesome, and they're pretty important:
- The district kept adopting new budget-stabilization plans before finishing the old ones, which made it hard for anyone, including the board, to track what was actually being cut.12
- Its multiyear projections are balanced only by assuming large, unspecified future reductions, a line item literally labeled "Other Adjustments," and FCMAT dings this in at least six separate questions.13
- The district approved raises in early 2026, one of them a 14% ongoing increase, while its own projections showed a structural deficit, and it filed the required public disclosures late.14
- The chief business official left in December, the superintendent was still interim when the data was pulled, and a lot of basic back-office evidence (bank reconciliations, system access reviews, an internal audit function) either wasn't there or couldn't be produced.15
These things are definitely a huge bummer, but none of them is news to anyone who has been following OUSD for the last couple of decades.16 The report is valuable, but the numbers it uses are nine months old, and it only annotates the changes that have happened since then.
What happens if you re-score it today
For "fun," I read all of the questions in the report. I looked closely at all 60 of the district's "no" answers and asked: if FCMAT answered this today, using the same criteria but the September actuals and the 2026-27 budget, would the answer change? Then I went back through the ones I'd ruled out with the district's own filings in hand. The TL;DR is that (in my opinion) a dozen answers have a real case for flipping to "yes," and the score lands somewhere between 43.4% and 35.1%, depending on what mood you're in. Even a meh mood puts it in the Moderate band.
Disclaimer: FCMAT doesn't publish how much each question is worth, so I had to estimate the weights from the report's section totals.17 Consider this a best effort by a person who doesn't get paid to do this kinda stuff. The full method is in the appendix below.
First, here's what has changed in general since Second Interim:
- OUSD ended the year with $22 million more in restricted reserves than it projected in January.18 The unrestricted side went the other way: the deficit came in about $9 million worse than projected.19
- District staff has moved aggressively to budget restricted dollars first, a long-overdue change in process that County Superintendent Castro has praised and that this scoring doesn't account for.20
- The "Other Adjustments" that totaled $92.7 million in January are down to $40 million still unidentified, now that this year's $30 million in cuts has an itemized list.21
- Total spending in the adopted budget for 2026-27 is $43 million below what the district actually spent in 2025-26.22
- In May, the board self-identified its Third Interim report as "Positive," meaning it expects to meet its obligations, after two "qualified" reports earlier in the year. It isn't a legal certification, and the county treats it as conditional, but FCMAT's report doesn't mention it at all.23
You probably won't see these mentioned in the broader narrative about OUSD, but to me they show a positive trajectory since Second Interim that this report doesn't capture. So here are the fifteen questions with any case at all, each answered "No" in the report based on January data, grouped by my read on how likely each one is to flip to "Yes" once the progress above is taken into account. I included three I think are unlikely, so you can see why. You can play too!
Likely
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- No plan as of Second Interim.
- Since then
- June's plan cuts the special ed contribution 10%. FCMAT asks for a plan, not results; the cut wasn't realized in 2025-26.
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- No transfers to either fund.
- Since then
- The 2026-27 budget sends $2.98M to self-insurance. Adult ed gets nothing, which is the weak spot.
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- No self-insurance transfer, despite $2.06M the year before.
- Since then
- The 2026-27 budget has $2.98M, above last year's $2.24M actual.
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- A $20.6M unrestricted deficit projected for 2025-26.
- Since then
- The 2026-27 budget projects an $8.0M surplus, if this year's $30M in cuts land. If "current year" still means 2025-26, the deficit was $30.0M. Note 19
Plausible
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Restricted money was piling up: 78% of the ending balance.
- Since then
- The restricted balance fell $61.5M in 2025-26 and is budgeted down to $18.2M by 2028-29. Staff now call restricted-first standing practice, though restricted money was a larger share of the balance at year-end. Note 20
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Cuts were made before the board adopted a plan.
- Since then
- The board adopted a plan in June and met both of the county's September conditions. The county decides by November 8. Note 21
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- The SEIU disclosure came after approval, and a 2023 one was unsigned.
- Since then
- The latest contract, OEA's in June, came with a signed disclosure, though at the same meeting as the vote. Note 14
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- A plan was approved but not implemented, and plans keep changing.
- Since then
- June's plan hasn't changed, it tracks 31 actions, and this year's $30M is itemized. Results come December 9. Note 21
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- No documentation of monitoring.
- Since then
- Special ed is the plan's top priority ($14.9M), and the budget tracks the contribution trend.
Uncertain
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- The special ed contribution was budgeted $7.3M below the prior year's $127.9M actual.
- Since then
- The adopted budget raises total contributions to restricted programs, but it doesn't break out special ed alone, so the fix can't be confirmed.
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Second Interim dropped the detail.
- Since then
- The June budget restored it, but FCMAT asks about interims. The December 9 First Interim decides it. Note 4
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Late SEIU disclosure and missed county-review deadlines.
- Since then
- OEA's contract looks compliant, but the SEIU lapse is still within FCMAT's three-year window. Note 14
Unlikely
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Nothing set aside for legal claims.
- Since then
- The new $4.2M set-aside is for budget balancing, and the budget lists no contingent liabilities.
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Six grants charged no overhead.
- Since then
- One now does. The other five, including $8.4M of Prop 28 arts money, still don't.
What FCMAT found, and what changed
- January (Second Interim)
- Policies exist, but staff didn't know them.
- Since then
- New spending controls are in place, but nothing shows staff know the policies now.
By “mood” I really mean level of optimism. I’m personally in the “meh” camp but you know, a lot of folks think I’m a shill so don’t trust me!
How does Oakland compare?
Since the start of 2024 there have been 40 K-12 FHRAs. Oakland's 47.7% ranks 11th from the top, tied with tiny Dunsmuir Elementary, against an average of 38.8%.24
- High 40% or more
- Moderate 25% to 39.9%
- Low under 25%
- Santa Rosa City Schools ’26, published Jan 23, 2026, opens the PDF report57.0%, High band
- Sacramento City USD ’25, published Dec 10, 2025, opens the PDF report50.7%, High band
- San Francisco USD ’24, published Apr 26, 2024, opens the PDF report50.7%, High band
- Hayward USD ’25, published Feb 7, 2025, opens the PDF report50.1%, High band
- San Francisco COE ’24, published Apr 26, 2024, opens the PDF report50.1%, High band
- Rincon Valley Union SD ’26, published Mar 20, 2026, opens the PDF report49.9%, High band
- Amador USD ’25, published Jul 18, 2025, opens the PDF report49.9%, High band
- Pacifica SD ’26, published May 13, 2026, opens the PDF report49.3%, High band
- San Ysidro SD ’26, published Mar 27, 2026, opens the PDF report48.9%, High band
- Yreka Union ESD ’25, published Feb 5, 2025, opens the PDF report48.4%, High band
- Oakland USD ’26, published Oct 29, 2026, opens the PDF report47.7%, High band
- Dunsmuir ESD ’25, published May 16, 2025, opens the PDF report47.7%, High band
- Antioch USD ’26, published May 14, 2026, opens the PDF report46.4%, High band
- Franklin-McKinley ESD ’25, published Jun 11, 2025, opens the PDF report44.9%, High band
- San Francisco USD ’26, published Aug 13, 2026, opens the PDF report42.9%, High band
- Coachella Valley USD ’25, published Mar 13, 2025, opens the PDF report42.6%, High band
- Oak Run ESD ’24, published Jun 17, 2024, opens the PDF report41.3%, High band
- Amador COE ’25, published Jul 18, 2025, opens the PDF report40.6%, High band
- Live Oak ESD ’24, published May 6, 2024, opens the PDF report40.3%, High band
- San Ramon Valley USD ’25, published Jun 17, 2025, opens the PDF report38.7%, Moderate band
- Sonoma Valley USD ’25, published Nov 12, 2025, opens the PDF report38.6%, Moderate band
- Cuyama Joint USD ’24, published Sep 24, 2024, opens the PDF report38.3%, Moderate band
- Glendale USD ’24, published Oct 7, 2024, opens the PDF report38.1%, Moderate band
- Los Angeles USD ’26, published Sep 30, 2026, opens the PDF report37.9%, Moderate band
- Burbank USD ’26, published May 12, 2026, opens the PDF report37.4%, Moderate band
- Hacienda La Puente USD ’25, published Jul 16, 2025, opens the PDF report36.9%, Moderate band
- Vallejo City USD ’25, published May 13, 2025, opens the PDF report36.3%, Moderate band
- Petaluma City Schools ’26, published Apr 7, 2026, opens the PDF report34.6%, Moderate band
- Green Point ESD ’24, published Jul 23, 2024, opens the PDF report34.6%, Moderate band
- Apple Valley USD ’25, published Nov 5, 2025, opens the PDF report31.2%, Moderate band
- Cascade Union ESD ’25, published Apr 4, 2025, opens the PDF report30.2%, Moderate band
- Duarte USD ’24, published Sep 25, 2024, opens the PDF report28.8%, Moderate band
- Mountain Empire USD ’25, published Apr 9, 2025, opens the PDF report28.7%, Moderate band
- West Contra Costa USD ’24, published May 24, 2024, opens the PDF report27.0%, Moderate band
- Pleasanton USD ’26, published Mar 17, 2026, opens the PDF report25.7%, Moderate band
- Alum Rock Union ESD ’24, published Oct 30, 2024, opens the PDF report24.7%, Low band
- Lassen Union HSD ’25, published Nov 13, 2025, opens the PDF report22.3%, Low band
- East Side Union HSD ’25, published Apr 29, 2025, opens the PDF report21.3%, Low band
- Saddleback Valley USD ’26, published May 6, 2026, opens the PDF report21.2%, Low band
- Chawanakee USD ’25, published Aug 7, 2025, opens the PDF report19.2%, Low band
K-12 reports published January 2024 to October 2026. Each name links to its report.
Note the improvement of San Francisco Unified, from 50.7% in 2024 to 42.9% this August.25 That's a 7.8-point drop in a little over two years, mostly from fixing processes like enrollment reporting, budget monitoring, and position control, even as SF's deficit got worse. They are still rated "High", of course!
What to make of all this
The FHRA is an accurate description of where the district's systems were in January, written by paid, independent experts. It is not a verdict on the past nine months. The numbers from those nine months are mixed but better in general, and the things that will actually move the needle on any of this are coming in December and January.4 Please stay tuned for that.
Appendix: At-Home FHRA Scoring Methodology
I couldn't find any real information on how FCMAT weights things, so I tried to use simple math to extrapolate weights with some semblance of accuracy. Maybe it's wrong! What follows is how I came up with this, so you can decide yourself if it's reasonable or BS. I did use AI (Claude Opus 5.5) to sort through the questions, but I definitely read them and rated them myself, which is why you should read them too... Go humans!
The question. For each of the 60 "no" answers in the report, I asked: if FCMAT answered this question today, applying the same criterion but using the 2025-26 unaudited actuals (approved September 9, 2026) and the 2026-27 adopted budget (approved June 24, 2026) as the current data, would the answer change? "Today" means the current fiscal year is 2026-27 and the two subsequent years are 2027-28 and 2028-29, which is how the adopted budget's multiyear projection is framed.
The weights. FCMAT doesn't publish how many points each question is worth. The report does show how much each of the 20 sections contributed to the 47.7%. I approximated each question's weight as its section's contribution divided by the number of "no" answers in that section. So in Section 7, which contributed 3.0% with three "no"s, each is worth about 1.0%; in Section 20, which contributed 1.1% with three "no"s, each is worth about 0.4%. The section figures sum to 47.6%, which matches the published score within rounding. Under this method most core fiscal questions land near 1%, and audit, facilities, and special education questions land between 0.1% and 0.4%.
The evidence. I started with the FCMAT report itself: its own notes about events after January, and the Appendix A tables that lay the Second Interim, Third Interim, estimated actuals, unaudited actuals, and 2026-27 budget side by side. Then I checked OUSD's own public filings since January: the Third Interim report, the 2026-27 adopted budget and 2025-26 unaudited actuals (including their state SACS forms), the Stabilization Plan progress reports from September and October, the board's response to the county, and the June teachers' contract.26 Where nothing public settles a question, it stays "no." This probably still errs on the side of a higher score.
The limits. The weights are inferred, not official. Several of the flips depend on reading phrases like "approved and implemented" or "reasonable levels" with some level of consistency, and none of this touches the superseding conditions that set the High rating, which is the main point of the post.
The arithmetic. In a bad mood, only the four "likely" flips (7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 8.1) and the strongest "plausible" one (20.5) count, about 4.3 points, taking the score from 47.7% to 43.4%, still High. In a meh mood, add 2.7, 3.6, 6.8, 20.4, and 3.3, about 8.4 points in all, for 39.3%, just inside the Moderate band. In a good mood, flip all fifteen, including 8.3 and 6.7, which can't be confirmed yet, and the three I think are unlikely (12.5, 13.7, 15.7), for 35.1%. The overall rating is High in every mood, because the going-concern notice, the qualified certifications, and at least six of the nine material-weakness findings (2.5, 4.3, 6.4, 12.2, 12.3, 19.1) are still in place.
The fifteen questions are all in the calculator above, with what FCMAT found in January and what changed since (open "What FCMAT found, and what changed" on any row). A few hinge on things that haven't happened yet: the 2026-27 First Interim on December 9 should settle 3.3 and 8.3, and the county's final budget decision, due by November 8, bears on 3.6. When those land, I'll update this.
Appendix: The Rest of the "No" Questions
These are the other 45 "No" answers, worth about 35 of the 47.7 points. For these, the later filings either show the same thing FCMAT found or don't speak to the question at all; most are about processes, controls, and governance that no budget report can answer. Some may well have been fixed since August, but the report gives no basis to assert that, so this is where we end up.
Show all 45 questions
| # | The question, in plain English |
|---|---|
| 1.2 | Was the most recent audit presented to the board on time? |
| 1.3 | Were the last three audits free of material weaknesses? |
| 2.1 | Are budget assumptions and projections written, reasonable, and clear? |
| 2.5 | Has the county approved the budget unconditionally for three years running? (material weakness) |
| 2.9 | Does the district avoid counting estimated carryover in its adopted budget? |
| 2.11 | Is there a followed procedure for evaluating grants' long-term cost? |
| 3.5 | Do the district's explanations of budget variances actually explain them? |
| 3.9 | Were all interim reports and actuals filed on time over three years? |
| 4.2 | Are all bank accounts reconciled on time? |
| 4.3 | Does the cash flow forecast cover this year and next? (material weakness) |
| 4.6 | Does interfund borrowing follow the Education Code? |
| 6.4 | Did the district identify how it would pay for its 2025-26 raises before approving them? (material weakness) |
| 6.5 | Were settlements over three years at or under the funded COLA? |
| 8.2 | Is the district projected to avoid deficits in both of the next two years? |
| 8.4 | Has deficit spending gone down over the past two years, per the actuals? |
| 9.3 | Has the district verified benefits eligibility for employees and dependents in the last five years? |
| 10.8 | Was CALPADS enrollment data certified on time? |
| 10.10 | Does the district meet TK class-size and staffing ratios? |
| 11.4 | Are facilities fully used by state loading standards? |
| 11.5 | Does the budget reflect a real facilities-maintenance plan? |
| 12.2 | Can it keep the minimum reserve in the next two years? (material weakness) |
| 12.3 | If not, is there a board-approved plan in the projection to restore it? (material weakness) |
| 12.4 | Is the unrestricted balance stable without unsubstantiated cuts? |
| 13.1 | Does the district avoid paying for ongoing costs with one-time money? |
| 13.2 | Is the share of unrestricted spending on salaries and benefits at or below the state average? |
| 13.3 | Is that share at or below the district's own prior two years? |
| 13.5 | For jobs funded by one-time or restricted money, is there a plan when that money ends? |
| 13.8 | Are balance sheet accounts reconciled at each interim and year-end? |
| 14.2 | Does the district actually use its financial system for decisions? |
| 15.2 | Are system access rights reviewed when people leave and at least annually? |
| 15.5 | Are prior-year accruals cleared during the year? |
| 15.8 | Is there a way to report suspected fraud and follow up? |
| 15.9 | Is there an internal audit function? |
| 16.1 | Has the CBO been in the job more than two years? |
| 16.2 | Has the superintendent been in the job more than two years? |
| 16.4 | Do site and department administrators get real budget training? |
| 16.7 | Do all board members take budget and governance training every two years? |
| 17.1 | Do the multiyear projections have detailed, industry-standard assumptions? |
| 17.3 | Does the district use its own projections when making decisions? |
| 17.4 | If the projection uses a broad adjustment line, is there a detailed list behind it? |
| 18.3 | Is the self-insurance fund actuarially valued with a plan for unfunded liabilities? |
| 19.1 | Does position control capture all staffing costs, including subs and overtime? (material weakness) |
| 19.4 | Is a funding source identified for every new position before the board approves it? |
| 19.5 | Does the board approve new positions before they're posted? |
| 20.6 | Is the special education identification rate at or below county and state averages? |
Footnotes
-
FCMAT, Fiscal Health Risk Analysis: Oakland Unified School District, final report dated October 29, 2026. Unless I say otherwise, every Oakland number in this post comes from it: the scoring basis and rules (pp. 6, 8, 10-12, 38), the question-by-question narratives and post-January notes (pp. 13-38), and the Appendix A tables (pp. 40-46). ↩
-
For example, District 2 candidate Arielle Fleisher, endorsed in Empower Oakland's voter guide, posted on Instagram on October 30 that "of the ~1000 school districts in California, only 12 are rated high risk financially," and that Oakland's score puts it at "the 4th highest risk in the whole state." Both numbers seem to come from the San Francisco Chronicle's story that same day (Jill Tucker, "Oakland schools touted financial progress. An analysis paints a darker picture"), which reported that the district's own letter to families named 11 other districts FCMAT had rated high risk, and that Oakland's score was "among the top four." Those 12 appear to be the FHRAs FCMAT published in 2026, not every high-risk district in California. FCMAT only reviews districts that have tripped an alarm, and every one of the 40 FHRAs since 2024 came out High, including Pleasanton at 25.7% and Saddleback Valley at 21.2%. By my count Oakland is fifth of the 2026 dozen and 11th of the 40 (see the comparison chart). ↩
-
The Second Interim report reflects data as of January 31, 2026, and the board adopted it March 11, 2026. FCMAT used it "because it was the most current financial report at the time the going concern notice was issued" (report, p. 6). ↩
-
The 2026-27 First Interim report covers the district's finances through October 31 and has to be approved within 45 days, which lands on December 15 (Education Code § 42130). It comes with a certification under § 42131: positive means the district "will meet its financial obligations" for this year and the next two, and qualified means it "may not." OUSD's run of qualified certifications is one of the conditions that keeps its rating High (report, p. 10), so a positive one that the county accepts would matter. The district says it will bring the First Interim to the board on December 9 (October 28 update). The 2025-26 independent audit is the other one to watch. A clean one rolls the 2022-23 material weakness out of the three-year window FCMAT looks at (questions 1.2 and 1.3). ↩ ↩2
-
FCMAT was created by the Legislature in Assembly Bill 1200 (1991) and Education Code § 42127.8. It's run out of the Kern County Superintendent of Schools and funded by the state budget plus "modest fees to requesting agencies" (report, pp. 3-4). It has helped districts more than 2,000 times since it was formed. ↩
-
From the report's own guidelines: FCMAT reports "focus on systems and processes that may need improvement," and the ones "that may be functioning well are generally not commented on" (report, p. 7). ↩
-
The going-concern notice comes from Education Code § 42127.6, which doesn't itself mention an FHRA. The requirement comes from the state budget act, and the study agreement in the report's Appendix B says so: FCMAT studied OUSD "in accordance with state budget act provisions" because of the going-concern designation. Even so, it wasn't instant. The notice came April 16, the county and FCMAT discussed an FHRA on April 28, and the district signed the agreement August 21 (report, p. 6). The district also appealed the designation to the State Superintendent (Resolution No. 2526-0018, May 13, 2026). The California Department of Education denied that appeal on May 14, according to the county's annual report on OUSD's fiscal solvency (September 15, 2026). Fun fact: this isn't OUSD's first FHRA. FCMAT did one in 2017 (FCMAT, August 2017), and the report notes OUSD met the criteria for one several more times while it was in receivership, but FCMAT skipped them because the county trustee already knew the risks (p. 6). ↩
-
By my count, 134 questions across the 20 numbered sections (report, pp. 13-38). FCMAT's Fiscal Health page describes the tool, and any district can run it on itself; FCMAT's report even suggests doing it every year (p. 10). ↩
-
The bands are on page 38 of the report, and FCMAT's Fiscal Health page gives the same cutoffs. The section-by-section breakdown on page 12 adds up to 47.6%, and FCMAT warns that the section values "are provided for information only" because the score isn't calculated by section. ↩
-
Page 38: "The existence of any condition from the 'Budget and Fiscal Status' section, and/or a material weakness, will supersede the score above." OUSD has both. Two of the five Budget and Fiscal Status conditions apply (three consecutive qualified interim certifications, and the going-concern designation), and the district answered "No" on nine of the material-weakness questions: 2.5, 3.6, 4.3, 6.4, 7.2, 8.3, 12.2, 12.3, and 19.1 (pp. 10-11). Any one of those would make the rating High, so a score of 30% would still come out High. ↩
-
Fieldwork was done virtually, August 25-27 (report, p. 7). The later documents FCMAT annotated are the Third Interim report (data through April 30, approved May 27, 2026), the 2025-26 estimated actuals and 2026-27 adopted budget (approved June 24, 2026), and the 2025-26 unaudited actuals (approved September 9, 2026) (report, p. 6). By my count they show up in about 14 places in the question narratives. ↩
-
This is the main theme of the report's summary (p. 8), which describes the board "often introducing new plans before fully implementing existing ones." ↩
-
Questions 2.1, 8.2, 12.2, 12.3, 12.4, 17.1, and 17.4 all turn on the "Other Adjustments" line (pp. 13, 24, 27-28, 35-36). ↩
-
Questions 6.5, 6.7, and 6.8 (pp. 19-20). The 14% raise went to classified staff in SEIU 1021, retroactive to July 2025, against a 2.3% state cost-of-living increase (contract). The board approved it in late February; the required public disclosure didn't come until May 13. ↩
-
Questions 16.1 and 16.2 cover leadership tenure (pp. 34-35); 4.2, 15.2, and 15.9 cover bank reconciliations, system access, and internal audit (pp. 18, 33-34). On the departures, see KQED, "Oakland Schools in Turmoil After 2 Key Officials Depart Over Budget Crisis" (December 18, 2025). Superintendent Saddler was interim from June 2025 until the board approved a contract as superintendent on May 13, 2026, which runs through June 2027 (KQED, May 13, 2026). FCMAT's two-year clock on question 16.2 runs from her start date. ↩
-
For a longer history of outside reviewers saying the same things, see note 5 of Alameda County Says OUSD's Progress Is Real. ↩
-
The method, and its limits, are in the appendix at the end. ↩
-
The 2025-26 ending General Fund balance came in at $170.1M against $148.4M projected at Second Interim. The whole gain was restricted: $137.8M vs $115.8M. Report Appendix A, Table A-4 (pp. 45-46). ↩
-
The unrestricted deficit was $30.0M in the unaudited actuals, against $20.6M projected at Second Interim (report, item 8.4 and Table A-4). The year-end unrestricted balance still landed close to January's projection, about $32M, because the starting balance was restated up by $9.2M. This is an example of "restricted first" budgeting that FCMAT wants to see: in May the board approved charging eligible past General Fund costs to restricted funds (Resolution 2526-0019). The Third Interim showed that as an $8.8M transfer during the year; the unaudited actuals record it instead as a correction to the prior year's books, which the district's presentation calls "an accounting change" in how those shifts are shown. Same dollars either way, and the county reviewed the change (next note). So both things are true: the 2025-26 unrestricted deficit came in about $9M worse than January's projection, and moving past costs to restricted funds covered it. ↩
-
In her September 15, 2026 letter conditionally approving the 2026-27 budget, Castro called the shift "a material change in budgeting methodology," and her June 18 AB 1200 letter called it "a positive budgeting practice." I wrote about both in Alameda County Says OUSD's Progress Is Real. FCMAT still answered "No" on question 2.7 (does the district spend restricted money first?), because restricted money was still most of the balance. But the year-end numbers show the drawdown: the restricted balance fell from $199.3 million to $137.8 million during 2025-26 (report, Table A-4), and in May the board authorized reclassifying eligible past General Fund costs to other funds, with an ongoing cost-allocation review (Resolution 2526-0019). Staff now call restricted-first "standing practice" (October 28 update). That's why 2.7 is in the calculator, though by FCMAT's own measure restricted money was a larger share of the balance at year-end (81%) than in January (78%). ↩
-
At Second Interim the multiyear projection leaned on $36.0M (2026-27) and $56.7M (2027-28) of unidentified cuts (report, item 2.1 and Table A-4). The adopted budget still carried this year's ~$30M as a placeholder, but the September 23 progress report itemizes it: $39.3M in targeted actions, each with an owner and a status. What's left is about $30M for 2027-28 and $10M for 2028-29, which the board's own September resolution says "have not yet been identified, board-approved, or implemented"; it commits to acting on them by February 24, 2027. That's why the related questions stay "No." ↩
-
$882.0M budgeted for 2026-27 against $924.7M actually spent in 2025-26, a $42.7M cut. The adopted budget also projects an $8.0M unrestricted surplus, the first since 2022-23 (2023-24 ended about $193,000 short), and a reserve of about 3.4%, above the 2% statutory floor and the 3% local target (report, Tables A-2 and A-4). Both depend on this year's $30M in cuts, which the county says "still require additional support to implement" (September 15 letter). ↩
-
The board adopted Resolution No. 2526-0137 on May 27, 2026, calling the Third Interim report "Positive." A Third Interim (technically the end-of-year projection) was only required because the Second Interim was qualified, and the county's June 18 letter (included in the OEA agreement packet) says it "does not legally receive a certification." The county calls OUSD's self-assessment "strictly conditional" on carrying out its stabilization plan. Its September 15 annual report on OUSD's fiscal solvency still says the Third Interim "reflects significant improvement" over the Second Interim, while adding that the budget is "structurally not sustainable without further reductions." FCMAT uses the Third Interim's numbers in several places but says nothing about its self-assessment. ↩
-
Scores are read from the Score Breakdown table in each report, all listed on the FCMAT reports index; each name in the chart links to its PDF. Two notes: the 2024 San Francisco COE report says 51.1% in its text and 50.1% in its table, and I used the table. Glendale's March 2026 follow-up is a management letter with no re-score, so it's excluded. ↩
-
Compare SFUSD's April 2024 FHRA with its August 2026 FHRA. The 2026 report's appendix lists all three of SFUSD's scores: 38.4% in 2022, 50.7% in 2024, and 42.9% in 2026, every one of them rated High overall. The biggest drops in "No" answers between 2024 and 2026 were in enrollment and attendance (8 to 2), budget monitoring (7 to 3), and position control (6 to 3), while its deficit-spending section went from 0 "No"s to 4, with a projected $161 million unrestricted deficit for 2025-26 (2026 report, item 8.1 and Appendix A). In other words, SF's score improved mostly on process, while dollars got worse. The 2024 score made the news (San Francisco Chronicle, May 6, 2024); the improvement this year mostly didn't. ↩
-
All on OUSD's Legistar: the Third Interim report (May 27, 2026); the 2026-27 adopted budget and its presentation (June 24); the 2025-26 unaudited actuals (September 9); the Financial Stabilization Implementation Plan progress report (September 23) and update (October 28); Resolution 2627-0010, the board's response to the county (September 23); the OEA agreement and its AB 1200 disclosure (June 24); Resolution 2526-0019 on restricted-first budgeting (May 27); and the county's September 15 annual report on OUSD's fiscal solvency. Where a calculator note leans on one of these, it links to the footnote that cites it. ↩